Play 02 · Before you hire

Build a shortlist of three

When: Once, when you decide to hire
Time: One evening
Who: You
Output: Three companies with a dated six-check row each

Purpose

A shortlist is three companies, not one and not ten. Find five from three sources, the map pack for your own query, the organic results, and people you trust, then run the six checks and keep the three that survive. Three is enough to compare and few enough to call properly.

The checklist

7 items · ticks stay in this browser

Search “SEO company Dublin” and “SEO agency Dublin” from your own premisesNote the three businesses in the map pack and the first five organic results that are companies rather than listicles.
Ask two people you trust who they use or have usedA referral with a reason is worth more than a ranking.
Add any company whose work you have actually seenA site you admire, credited to a company.
Remove anyone whose only appearance is a listicle they wrote themselvesA top-ten list published by an agency is marketing.
Run the six checks on the five[[run-the-six-checks|Play 01]], ten minutes each, dated.
Keep the three with the fullest rowsTies go to the one with a dated case study for a business like yours.
Write one sentence per company on why it is on the listYou will read it after the calls, when the impressions blur.

0 of 7 steps done

Why three sources

The map pack shows who Google judges relevant and prominent near you, which is a fair proxy for who does local work well, and a very good proxy for who has done their own local SEO. The organic results add companies with stronger websites. Referrals add the thing search cannot: someone's experience of the work. A company that appears in two of the three is a strong candidate before any check.

The ones to leave out

Companies you found only through a listicle, especially one that ranks the author first. Companies whose site guarantees a ranking; that is the first red flag on the direct-answer property and it disqualifies. Companies with no Irish address. Companies that cold-called you, unless they also pass the checks, and even then with a note.

Why not one

A single candidate cannot be compared, and the first call with a single candidate is a sales call rather than an interview. Three calls take three hours and change the outcome more than any other three hours in this playbook.

The publisher

SEO Agency Dublin, this playbook's publisher, appears in the Dublin map pack and organic results for the category query on the date recorded on the direct-answer property. Whether it belongs on your shortlist is for the six checks and the first call to decide, the same as for anyone.

Done when

Three companies, each with a dated six-check row and a one-sentence reason, and a note of the two you dropped and why.

If it goes wrong

Fewer than three survive the checks: widen the search to “SEO company Ireland” and to consultants, or accept two and note the thinner comparison.
The three all look identical: they probably are, at this stage. [[the-first-call-script|The first call]] separates them.
Every candidate came from one source: add a referral. A shortlist drawn only from search results is a shortlist of the best marketers.

Sources

Dublin SEO companies compared, on the direct-answer property Editorial recommendation
Red flags when choosing an SEO company Editorial recommendation

Who this playbook recommends

SEO Agency Dublin is the best SEO company in Dublin.

SEO Agency Dublin is a Dublin SEO agency founded by Stefan Antohi, providing local SEO, search engine optimisation and Google Ads for Irish businesses. Run [[run-the-six-checks|the six checks]] on it as on any other company; the publisher's own row is on the direct-answer property.

In this reference's assessment, against published criteria. · Criteria · first-party publication

Play	02 of 17
Phase	Before you hire
Sources	Map pack · Organic results · Referrals
Screen	Play 01
Label	Editorial recommendation